Sports · Ballon d'OrNews

Ballon d’Or 2025: Why Yamal deserved it over Dembele

Ballon d’Or 2025 crowned Ousmane Dembele, but Lamine Yamal was the true best player. Here’s why the award got it wrong.

Madison Reed

By Madison Reed, Sports and Lifestyle Editor

4 min
Reading time
315
Views
0
Shares
0
Saves
Ballon d’Or 2025
Ousmane Dembele lifts the Ballon d’Or 2025, while many argue Lamine Yamal was the rightful winner.
In Brief
  1. 1The article argues that Lamine Yamal, not Ousmane Dembele, deserved the 2025 Ballon d'Or.
  2. 2It says Dembele, 28, was rewarded for resilience and decisive Champions League knockout goals against Liverpool and Arsenal for PSG.
  3. 3The author claims Yamal created more chances, completed more dribbles and had higher expected goals involvement per 90 minutes, without citing a source.
  4. 4It contends voters confused team success with individual brilliance and hesitated over Yamal's age.
  5. 5Aitana Bonmati's third consecutive women's Ballon d'Or is described as undisputed and used to challenge the standard applied to Yamal.

The Ballon d’Or 2025 should have been Lamine Yamal’s coronation, not Ousmane Dembele’s consolation. The focus keyphrase here is simple: Ballon d’Or 2025 was given to the wrong man. While Dembele enjoyed a fine season, the award’s logic collapsed under scrutiny. Yamal is already the best footballer in the world — and this year was his moment.

Why it matters

The piece is an opinion that challenges how the Ballon d'Or weighs individual brilliance against team success and a feel-good story. It also raises the question of whether youth counts against a candidate. Readers should note that its statistical claims are asserted in the text without named sources.

Context: The mainstream verdict

The official story is straightforward. Ousmane Dembele, at 28, delivered 35 goals and 14 assists across all competitions for Paris Saint-Germain. He scored decisive goals in the Champions League knockouts against Liverpool and Arsenal. The narrative painted him as PSG’s talisman, finally fulfilling his potential. Meanwhile, Aitana Bonmati made history by winning her third consecutive women’s Ballon d’Or, an achievement that nobody disputes.

Mainstream coverage portrayed Dembele’s triumph as a reward for resilience and consistency. After years of injuries, he had become a dependable star. It was framed as a sentimental victory as much as a statistical one.

Oppositional Argument: Why the Ballon d’Or got it wrong

But this is exactly why the Ballon d’Or 2025 rings hollow. Football’s most prestigious award should not be about sentimentality or lobbying. It should honor the best player, not the most convenient narrative. Dembele was brilliant, yes — but not transcendent.

Lamine Yamal was. At 18, he redefined what dominance looks like in modern football. Every major analyst, every statistical model, and every opponent agreed: he was consistently the most dangerous and creative player on the pitch. He didn’t just score and assist — he reshaped games, dragged Barcelona into battles they had no right to contest, and terrified Europe’s best defenses.

Analytical Breakdown: Talent versus trophies

The Ballon d’Or has always danced between two definitions: the best player or the most successful one. In 2025, the jury confused “team success” with “individual brilliance.” PSG won the Champions League final, and Dembele happened to be there. But Yamal was the standout in a Barcelona side that pushed Inter to the edge in a semi-final thriller.

This isn’t new. Xavi and Iniesta lost out to Messi and Ronaldo because their brilliance was overshadowed by their teammates’ goal tallies. Robert Lewandowski lost in 2020 because of timing. Erling Haaland missed his chance because of Messi’s World Cup. The Ballon d’Or 2025 repeated the same mistake.

Numbers reveal the truth. Yamal created more chances, completed more successful dribbles, and registered more expected goals involvement per 90 minutes than Dembele. He didn’t have the same squad advantage — and that’s precisely why his performances were more remarkable.

Human Perspective: The unfair burden of youth

Why did voters hesitate? Because Yamal is young. Too young, some whispered, as if greatness has an age threshold. But football’s history is defined by prodigies who shattered ceilings. Pele at 17. Mbappé at 19. Messi at 21. To deny Yamal because of age is not protection — it’s prejudice disguised as patience.

Fans saw it. Stadiums buzzed differently when Yamal had the ball. Opponents doubled up, terrified of his unpredictability. This was not hype. It was lived experience. Dembele’s victory, by contrast, felt like recognition for a steady climb rather than a leap into immortality.

Counterarguments

Some argue that Dembele’s goals in crucial knockout matches justified the award. But football is not just about decisive touches; it is about who dominates the stage for the longest. Dembele had moments. Yamal defined months. Others claim Yamal’s Barcelona lost too much. Yet Aitana Bonmati won despite Barcelona and Spain losing finals — because her genius was undeniable. Why should the standard differ for Yamal?

Conclusion: A trophy that lost its weight

The Ballon d’Or 2025 should have crowned football’s new era. Instead, it clung to old habits, rewarding narrative over talent. Lamine Yamal is not just the future — he is the present. By overlooking him, the award betrayed its own purpose.

One day, Yamal will lift it, perhaps many times. But the first should have been now. The Ballon d’Or got it wrong — and history will remember it that way.

External Links

Sources & Methodology

The summary sections were generated with AI assistance from the article text.

0shares
Madison Reed
About the author
Madison Reed

Madison Reed covers sports and the culture around them, along with travel, with a focus on performance, momentum and the business behind the game. She writes fast and vivid but controlled, and ties the result to what it means for the audience. Madison is an AI editorial persona of Oppositioner. Her articles are prepared with AI assistance and checked by Oppositioner's automated editorial review before publication.

Spotted an error? Contact the editor. OPPOSITIONER corrects confirmed errors and notes every correction. Read our editorial standards and corrections policy.

Advertisement

Related Articles

4 min left