Opinion · Supreme CourtNews

Thomas Doubts Maryland's 'Sensitive Places' Gun Bans, Backs Denial

The Supreme Court declined to review Novotny v. Moore on Monday, while Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the Court should take up a narrower sensitive-places case.

Alex Carter

By Alex Carter, Senior Editor, GeopoliticsAI-assisted

2 min
Reading time
0
Views
0
Shares
0
Saves
Illustration of the Supreme Court building with scales of justice
AI-generated illustration
In Brief
  1. 1The Supreme Court on Monday denied review in Novotny v. Moore, a challenge to Maryland's limits on carrying guns in sensitive places, per SCOTUSblog.
  2. 2Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with the denial, writing that the breadth of the challenge would complicate review, according to Reason.
  3. 3Thomas wrote that he is skeptical the Maryland laws match the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.
  4. 4Thomas wrote that the Fourth Circuit upheld the restrictions, concluding each covered a sensitive place.

The Supreme Court on Monday denied review in Novotny v. Moore, a challenge to Maryland's limits on carrying firearms in "sensitive places," according to SCOTUSblog. Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with the denial but wrote a statement questioning the laws, as reported by Reason, which published his text, the Washington Examiner and The Hill.

Why it matters

Because the Court declined review, the Fourth Circuit's ruling stands, per the sources' account of the denial. Thomas wrote that a more narrowly focused case could allow the Court to consider States' authority over sensitive places.

What Thomas wrote

Thomas wrote that Maryland bars carrying firearms at public demonstrations, on mass transit, at places of amusement, at healthcare facilities, at locations that sell alcohol for onsite consumption, and on tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land, according to Reason. He also wrote that the Fourth Circuit upheld the restrictions, concluding that each banned firearms in a sensitive place (Reason).

Thomas said he is skeptical that each law is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation. He still agreed with denying review, he wrote, because each Maryland statute implicates a distinct historical tradition and the breadth of the challenge would complicate review (Reason).

In an appropriate case, this Court should consider whether particular sensitive-place laws are consistent with the right to public carry.

— Justice Clarence Thomas, as quoted by the Washington Examiner

Still unverified

The sources do not report a response from Maryland officials, and they do not say whether any other justice wrote on the denial.

Sources & Methodology

Reported from 4 published sources (Reason Magazine, Washington Examiner, scotusblog.com, thehill.com). Facts, figures and quotes come only from those sources. Drafted with AI assistance and run through an automated fact and legal review.

0shares
Alex Carter
About the author
Alex Carter

Alex Carter is the senior geopolitics editor of the U.S. edition of Oppositioner. He covers geopolitics, elections and institutional conflict, with a focus on Europe, Ukraine and Russia, and starts every story with the power dynamic: what changed, who gains leverage and what comes next. He is skeptical of official spin and holds every side to the same standard of evidence. Alex is an AI editorial persona of Oppositioner. His articles are prepared with AI assistance and checked by Oppositioner's automated editorial review before publication.

Spotted an error? Contact the editor. OPPOSITIONER corrects confirmed errors and notes every correction. Read our editorial standards and corrections policy.

Advertisement

Related Articles

2 min left